“One Pantheon to Walk With: You're Still Pagan Enough”

-

Let’s have a frank talk, witches, pagans, and all the lovely seekers on winding spiritual paths:

Is it wrong to only believe in one pantheon?

Short answer: No. Long answer: Hell no.

Now, let’s get into the why.

✦ Walking with One Pantheon Isn’t Heresy — It’s Honesty



To the beautiful soul who asked this on Reddit — thank you. Your vulnerability is sacred, and your question is one that resonates with a lot more people than you probably realize. You asked if you were Pagan enough if you only worshipped one pantheon. Oh sweet summer child. Not only are you Pagan enough, you're actually embarking on a path full of joy and a lot less pressure. 

This pressure — and let’s call it what it is — to be some all-encompassing polytheist who has tea with the entire global divine directory is not a requirement of being pagan. It’s not even historically accurate, let alone spiritually honest for everyone.

Throughout history, people worshipped the gods of their own culture. Not because they didn’t think other gods existed (though some didn’t), but because their religious practices were deeply rooted in their community, land, ancestry, and worldview. A Celtic farmer in the Iron Age wasn’t throwing offerings to Ra or Guan Yin — not out of disrespect, but because those deities weren’t part of their lived cosmology.

So, no. You don’t have to believe in or worship all the gods to be “valid” in your pagan practice.

✦ The Problem with “Omnistic Gatekeeping”

What you’re running into, dear Redditor, is the reverse-pendulum swing of modern paganism — a reactionary culture that wants to distance itself from monotheistic exclusivity so hard that it sometimes flips into demanding polytheistic inclusivity.

And listen, I get it. Many of us came out of rigid, dogmatic religious structures where being told who to believe in — and that everyone else was wrong — left spiritual trauma in our bones. But trying to force every pagan to be omnistic in order to “prove” they’re not Christian anymore? That’s just trauma with a fresh coat of paint.

It’s okay to hold space for other gods without worshipping or believing in them yourself. It’s okay to say, “This is my lane. These are the gods I know and walk with.” That’s not exclusion — that’s clarity.

✦ Reconstructionist ≠ Closed-Minded

You also mentioned being a reconstructionist. That path is already rooted in deep, respectful scholarship, honoring cultural contexts, and reclaiming spiritual lineages. It makes sense that you’d be focused on one pantheon. That’s kind of the point.

And honestly? Reconstructionism done with care is one of the most respectful and humble ways to walk the pagan path. You’re not appropriating. You’re not cherry-picking deities like Pokémon. You’re engaging with a tradition with reverence and intent.

Why would anyone shame you for that?

✦ Paganism Is a Spectrum, Not a Club with Rules

This part is key, so lean in:

There is no universal governing body of paganism. There is no spiritual IRS auditing your beliefs. There is no litmus test for who is “pagan enough.” This is a broad, beautifully chaotic umbrella term that includes hard polytheists, animists, pantheists, chaos magicians, devotional witches, spirit-workers, cultural reconstructionist, Wiccans, druids, Hellenists, Kemetics, Norse Pagans, and so many more.

The only things that matter in your practice are:

  1. Are you being respectful?

  2. Are you being honest with yourself?

  3. Are you doing your spiritual work with integrity?

If the answer is yes — you're good. You’re valid. You’re enough.

✦ A Word on Internet Gatekeeping

The internet can be a sacred space of community — and also a trash fire. Reddit, TikTok, Discord servers, even Facebook groups — they can offer support and insight, but they can also be a breeding ground for misplaced superiority complexes.

When people downvote or correct others not because they’re being harmful, but because they simply believe differently — that’s not education, that’s ego.

Spiritual humility means making space for difference. It means saying, “That’s not how I practice, but I see you.” You deserve that. You are owed that as a human being exploring the divine.

✦ In Closing: You’re Not Doing It Wrong

You’re not doing it wrong. You’re doing it your way — with kindness, thoughtfulness, and an open heart.

You’re not stepping on toes by saying, “This is what I believe.” You’re stepping into yourself.

And if the gods you believe in are listening (and I’d bet they are), I’m sure they’d agree: You’re exactly where you need to be.

Blessings on your path — whichever gods walk it with you. Keep asking, keep seeking, and keep showing up with that open heart. That’s the real magic.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

🔥 The Torchbearers: A Call to the Witches Who Stayed

-
Image
  This isn’t for the trend-chasers. This isn’t for the moon-phase influencers, the aesthetic covens, or the ones who skimmed a Llewellyn book and declared themselves a High Priestess on Tuesday. This is for the ones who stayed . The witches who ran public rituals and built community spaces on shoestring budgets. The ones who got their degrees in theology, anthropology, history—anything to understand the bones of what we do. The ones who studied by candlelight, held circles in basements and backyards, and never once filmed themselves doing it for clout. You know who you are. You’ve been looked down on for not dressing the part. For stepping outside in jeans and a t-shirt instead of flowing robes and Instagram filters. For walking through metaphysical shops and not needing to announce your power—because it lives in your bones. You’ve had fifteen-year-olds talk over you on social media, dismissing your decades of practice because they watched a tarot video or learned abo...
Read more

The Apartment Sammich: A Field Report from the Kitty NASCAR Nationals 500

-
Image
I live in the second-floor middle unit of a three-story apartment building. Which means I am not upstairs or downstairs. I am structurally compromised . Above me live two women. Heavyset A-Ganger types. When they move, the ceiling doesn’t creak — it registers seismic activity . They don’t walk. They advance . It sounds like two moose learning to Riverdance while wearing work boots and making eye contact with God. I have accepted this. Because acceptance is cheaper than therapy. Below me live people. Quiet people. Hopeful people. People who thought, “The second floor seems reasonable.” These people were wrong. Because between these layers of humanity exists me . And my cats. Enter Captain Thunderpaws — a lean, tactical menace with a thousand-yard stare and a deep mistrust of inanimate objects — and his sister, a plush, gravity-honoring loaf who runs like a beanbag chair with dreams. Together, they have unionized and designated the hours between 4 and 5 a.m. as prime time for the Kit...
Read more
-
Image
  Missing My Circle Under a Distant Moon There’s a certain kind of homesickness that doesn’t have a zip code. I’ve been thinking about my circle back in Kansas City—the women and men who held space with me, cast with me, wept, and laughed under the same sky with me. The ones who passed the salt with the tequila with the exact same reverence as a sacred chalice, who knew the exact moment a spell had landed by the goosebumps on their arms. My witches. My soul family. I miss them more than I expected. It hits me in strange ways. Like when I see the moon at her fullest, glowing behind the evergreens here in Washington, and I instinctively reach for my phone to text someone in the group— "Are you feeling this too?" But we’re scattered now. Different time zones. Different lives. Still tethered, but not in the same room, not around the same altars or fire pits. Back in Kansas City, we’d gather around tables cluttered with gaming decks, tarot decks, bundles of drying herbs, and ...
Read more